Re: MOC Feedback for New Members

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · flare on Sun Nov 22, 2009 3:41 pm

Thunder-blade wrote:I'm sorry, but why would Flare be the minifig specialist? Just because you have the customized pieces doesn't mean you're actually GOOD at customizing them. Say with paint, decals, sharpie etc.

For the position/outfit/look/torso/legs/helment/legs/arms/hands/postion/face a minifigure should have. So it looks good in a Moc.

And it’s my idea! :X Razz

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · CommanderStone on Sun Nov 22, 2009 3:58 pm

Do you have to be in the guild? I' not in the guild but I would still love to critique!

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · The Jinja Ninja on Sun Nov 22, 2009 4:01 pm

Well, yes. If you're not good enough to get into the Guild, you should be asking for advice, not giving it.

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · CloneCommandoXion on Sun Nov 22, 2009 4:06 pm

PhiMa wrote:
Thunder-blade wrote:I'm sorry, but why would Flare be the minifig specialist? Just because you have the customized pieces doesn't mean you're actually GOOD at customizing them. Say with paint, decals, sharpie etc.

Exactly. Anyone can buy things, but it takes skill to actually make something good. It's like saying Legoboy is good at MOCs cause he has so many bricks and sets.

They're both right. You should change it to 'purist minifig specialist' because so far I haven't seen anything amazing from you (like decals, sharpie, and the others TB said).

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Phazezorz on Sun Nov 22, 2009 4:13 pm

The Jinja Ninja wrote:Well, yes. If you're not good enough to get into the Guild, you should be asking for advice, not giving it.

Exactly.

Not to say you wouldn't be good, or anything, but we need guildies only..

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · CloneCommandoXion on Sun Nov 22, 2009 4:15 pm

I'am very good at decal customization but I'm not sure if that would be my absolute specialty. I think it might be vehicles, or landscape...

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Troopa Daisy on Sun Nov 22, 2009 8:23 pm

I could be the custom minifig person! Smile

Couldn't I? Wink

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Tac on Mon Nov 23, 2009 2:19 am

I've added some stuff by peoples names, if you want me to add anythin' by yours post it here. Wink

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · MilitaMoose on Mon Nov 23, 2009 6:39 am

In which thread did you guys volunteer? I'm a Guild member, and want to sign up.

EDIT: Nevermind, found it.

Re: MOC Feedback · Cyrus on Mon Nov 23, 2009 8:14 am

I have a question, isn't the moc feedback to help members like me get into the guild so what good does having people comment on mini figs when mini fig arn't going to help get into the guild?

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Alpha on Mon Nov 23, 2009 10:20 am

You can, if they're close to Wuzzupbob quality, though you're going to get chastised for lacking building skills... unless you have both. Wink

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Phazezorz on Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:50 am

Hmm....

I'd probably be best in Vehicles....

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · CloneCommandoXion on Mon Nov 23, 2009 6:06 pm

Wouldn't I have some kind of fig decalling rank or something? After all in my legion comments some people said my commander looked closely to a wuzzie trooper. Wink

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · flare on Mon Nov 23, 2009 8:20 pm

Tac wrote:Hey new members, how would you like to get feedback on your MOCs? A group of guild members have kindly volunteered to give you some constructive critique on you creations! So, if you want some feedback just PM any guild member from this list:

Greeble/detail specialist:
Tac
Darth Yoda

[b]Custom Minifigure Specialists (decals, paint, sharpie, custom):
DarthPineapple
JediJoe

Purist Minifigure Specialists (regular Lego products, or custom pieces un-modded):
Jens
Alpha
Flare

World War II Specialist (help you make your WWII MOC come true):
Comrade Faie
Darth Bizzle

Special Effects Specialist (Masters of GIMP, Photoshop, etc.):
JediJoe
Alpha

Vehicles/hard suits specialist:
Wrecks

Stop Motion Specialist:
PizzaMovies

Misc. People that I don't know what they could do well in:
-Aki-
The Jinja Ninja
Troopa Daisy
Gerrard
RubbahBand
80-0
Clone Commander Xion
(insert name here)
667thLegion
VenatorClassCruiser

[/b]So what are you waitin' for? Get building!

There, Here is what it whould look like. Wink

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Alpha on Mon Nov 23, 2009 9:19 pm

Purist Minifigures? I use BrickArms... Razz

Besides that, mmkay...

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · -Aki- on Tue Nov 24, 2009 2:38 am

No, no, no. I should be in custom minifigs without a doubt. And Non-SW/WWII mocs.

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Axel on Tue Nov 24, 2009 2:44 am

Could you put me down for Custom Minifigures (painting) and maybe Greeble/Details?

It might also be a good idea to post what each Minifigure Customiser specialises in, eg: Thunder-blade (Waterslides and Sharpies), Darth Pineapple (Stickers), Chaotic Good (Waterslides), etc.

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · flare on Tue Nov 24, 2009 10:32 am

Axel wrote:Could you put me down for Custom Minifigures (painting) and maybe Greeble/Details?

It might also be a good idea to post what each Minifigure Customiser specialises in, eg: Thunder-blade (Waterslides and Sharpies), Darth Pineapple (Stickers), Chaotic Good (Waterslides), etc.

Alright, I'll add you to MY LIST WHICH IS NEAT AND ORGANIZED!

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · flare on Tue Nov 24, 2009 10:35 am

Greeble/detail specialist:
Tac
Darth Yoda

[b]Custom Minifigure Specialists (decals, paint, sharpie, custom):
DarthPineapple
JediJoe
[/size]-Aki-

Purist Minifigure Specialists (regular Lego products, or custom pieces un-modded):
Jens
Alpha
Flare

World War II Specialist (help you make your WWII MOC come true):
Comrade Faie
Darth Bizzle

Special Effects Specialist (Masters of GIMP, Photoshop, etc.):
JediJoe
Alpha

Vehicles/hard suits specialist:
Wrecks

Stop Motion Specialist:
PizzaMovies

Non-Star Wars:
-Aki-

[size=18]Misc. People that I don't know what they could do well in:
The Jinja Ninja
Troopa Daisy
Gerrard
RubbahBand
80-0
Clone Commander Xion
(insert name here)
667thLegion
VenatorClassCruiser

Re: MOC Feedback for New Members · Tac on Tue Nov 24, 2009 11:10 am

Updated with Flare's list. Smile

Thanks for that Flare. Wink